California Insurance Code section 758.5 prohibits an insurer from requiring you to use a specific repair shop. They may suggest one, and only after you have already chosen your own may they recommend an alternative, and they must tell you the choice is yours. You pick the shop. They pay the claim.
What the law actually says
California Insurance Code section 758.5 addresses what an insurer may and may not do about where your vehicle gets repaired. In plain terms, an insurer cannot require you to use a particular repair shop as a condition of settling your claim.
There is a narrow exception. An insurer may suggest or recommend a shop, but only when you have specifically asked for a referral, or after you have already selected a shop and the insurer then discloses that you are under no obligation to use their suggestion. The disclosure requirement exists precisely because the practice is otherwise coercive.
This is not obscure or contested. Automotive body shops in California cite it routinely. What is genuinely unusual is that almost nobody has written it down for RV, camper, and commercial vehicle owners, even though those are the owners most likely to be steered, because far fewer shops can do the work and carriers have stronger preferences about where it goes.
Requirement is prohibited: An insurer cannot make using their network shop a condition of paying your claim.
Disclosure is mandatory: If they recommend a shop after you have chosen one, they have to tell you that you are not obligated to use it.
Your policy still governs the amount: The law controls where the work is done. Your coverage still determines what is owed and what your deductible is.
It applies regardless of vehicle type: Nothing in it limits the protection to passenger cars.
What steering actually sounds like
Steering is rarely a flat refusal. It is a series of soft statements that add up to the impression that you have no real choice. Owners who recognize the pattern generally hold their ground, and owners who do not usually give in.
We cannot guarantee work at that shop: The carrier does not stand behind repair quality at any shop. Their network agreement is a pricing arrangement, not a quality assurance program.
That shop is not on our approved list: There is no legal requirement that a shop be on a carrier list, and being off it does not change what is owed on the claim.
It will take much longer if you go there: Sometimes true and sometimes a pressure tactic. Ask for the specific reason and get it in writing.
We will only pay our rate at that shop: Rates are negotiable and supplements are normal. This is a starting position, not a limit.
You will be responsible for the difference: The most effective line and the one that most often causes owners to fold. Ask for that statement in writing and it usually softens considerably.
Why this matters more on an RV than on a car
For a sedan, the practical difference between two collision shops is often small. For an RV, a fifth wheel, or a converted van, it is enormous, because the number of shops that can actually do the work is very small and a general body shop in a network may never have touched a coach.
A network shop with no RV experience will underwrite a claim on automotive assumptions. It will miss delamination behind the impact, it will not know that the slide opening needs measuring, and on a camper van conversion it will value a hundred thousand dollar build at zero because the VIN says cargo van.
That is the practical cost of steering on this vehicle class. It is not about preferring one shop over another. It is about whether the estimate reflects the vehicle you actually own.
What to do if you are being steered
Handle it calmly and in writing. The goal is not a confrontation, it is a documented record, and carriers behave differently when a record exists.
State your choice clearly. Tell the adjuster which shop you have selected and ask them to note it on the claim file.
Ask for it in writing. If you are told you will owe a difference or that the shop is unacceptable, request that in writing. This single request resolves most steering.
Reference the statute by name. Say that you understand California Insurance Code section 758.5 provides that you may choose your own repair facility. Being specific changes the tone of the call.
Let the shop talk to the adjuster. We deal with adjusters daily. Handing the technical conversation to us removes the pressure from you and moves it to ground we are comfortable on.
Escalate if it continues. The California Department of Insurance takes consumer complaints. Carriers know this, and the mention of it usually ends the discussion.
Why this statute exists at all
Anti steering rules were written because the incentives run the wrong way. A carrier pays the repair bill, so a carrier has a direct financial interest in where the work goes and at what rate. Left unregulated, that interest becomes pressure applied to somebody who has just had an accident and is not in a strong position to push back.
California is not unusual in this. Most states restrict steering in some form, and the common thread is a disclosure requirement: the insurer may express a preference, but it must make clear that the decision belongs to the policyholder. The disclosure exists because a preference expressed by the party holding the checkbook does not land as a suggestion.
It is worth being fair about network shops. Many are good, and a direct repair arrangement genuinely can streamline a claim. The problem is not that network shops are bad, it is that being in a network is a commercial arrangement about rates and cycle time, and consumers routinely mistake it for a quality credential.
The specific risk for RV, trailer, and conversion owners
For a passenger car, a carrier network is broad enough that the recommended shop is usually competent for the work. For an RV, a fifth wheel, a converted van, or a medium duty truck, that assumption fails, and it fails in a way that costs real money.
The shops that can physically accept a 40 foot coach in Orange County can be counted on one hand. A network list optimized for sedans will not contain many of them, and a general collision shop that agrees to take a coach it has never worked on will write a scope that misses the things that matter.
Delamination behind the impact: A body technician who has never worked a fiberglass sidewall will not tap test outward from the damage, so separated laminate two feet away never makes the estimate.
Slide opening squareness: If an impact racked a slide opening, the slide will bind and leak after the panel is repaired. Measuring that is not part of an automotive workflow.
Roof envelope breach: An overhead strike opens the seam between roof and sidewall. Missed at estimate, it becomes water damage the carrier later calls maintenance.
Conversion build content: Cabinetry, solar, lithium, plumbing, and pop tops are invisible on a VIN lookup. A shop that has not done conversions will not think to itemize them, and the carrier will not volunteer to pay.
Frame measurement: RV and truck chassis need measuring against published dimensions. A shop without the equipment will simply not raise the question.
What choosing your own shop does not change
Being clear about the limits keeps expectations accurate. This right controls the location of the repair, not the economics of the policy.
Your deductible is unchanged. Your coverage limits are unchanged. Whether a particular item is covered still depends on your policy and on the cause of the damage, and a shop cannot make an excluded item covered.
What choosing your own shop does change is who is writing the estimate and how thoroughly the damage gets documented, and on an RV that is usually the difference between a claim that pays for the actual repair and one that pays for the part of the repair that was visible from the parking lot.
Handling a claim from Buena Park
Our facility is at 23281 La Palma Ave, Yorba Linda, CA 92887, roughly 13 miles and about 20 minutes from Buena Park by way of the 91 and the 5. A large share of the claims we handle come from Buena Park, Anaheim, Fullerton, Cypress, La Palma, and the wider Orange County area.
Proximity matters more on a claim than people expect. An adjuster inspection, a teardown, and a supplement all move faster when the shop and the vehicle are in the same county as the adjuster, and when the vehicle can be brought in rather than transported twice.
All work is performed in shop. We do not run route service. Frame measurement, structural correction, and refinishing require equipment that does not travel, and a claim documented properly needs the vehicle somewhere it can be opened up and photographed under controlled conditions.
What to do next
If you have an open claim, call (714) 909-1444 with your carrier and claim number and we will tell you where it stands and what is likely missing from the scope. That conversation costs nothing and it frequently changes the outcome, whether or not the repair ends up here.
If you have damage and have not filed yet, photograph everything before you move the vehicle, get it out of the weather if the envelope is breached, and then call. Filing order matters, and a few minutes of guidance beforehand is worth considerably more than the same conversation a week later.
A written estimate is $150 and is credited against the repair once you authorize it. We bill every major carrier direct, so you cover your deductible and nothing else up front.
Frequently asked questions
Can my insurance company legally require me to use their shop in California?
No. California Insurance Code section 758.5 prohibits an insurer from requiring a specific repair facility. They may recommend one in defined circumstances, and when they do they must disclose that you are not obligated to use it. The choice of shop is yours.
Will I pay more out of pocket if I do not use the insurer's network shop?
You should not. Your deductible is set by your policy and does not change based on shop selection. If you are told you will owe a difference, ask for that in writing. Rates and scope are negotiated between the shop and the carrier through the supplement process, which is routine.
What is a direct repair program and do I have to use one?
A direct repair program is a commercial agreement between a carrier and a shop covering rates and process. It is a business arrangement, not a quality certification, and you are not obligated to use one. Plenty of excellent shops are outside every network, particularly in specialty vehicle work.
Does this apply to RVs, trailers, and commercial vehicles too?
Yes. The statute is not restricted to passenger cars. It matters more for these vehicles, because the pool of shops that can physically and technically do the work is far smaller and network options frequently have no relevant experience.
What should I say to the adjuster?
Something simple. State the shop you have chosen, ask them to note it on the file, and if you get pushback say you understand section 758.5 provides that you may select your own repair facility. Then ask for any contrary statement in writing. That normally ends it.
What if the carrier still refuses?
Ask for the refusal in writing and contact the California Department of Insurance, which accepts consumer complaints about claim handling. In practice, requesting the position in writing resolves the great majority of steering situations before it goes that far.
Related pages
Last reviewed by the OCRV Center shop team.